Registry Security

Overview: Secure tool registry operations, management, and supply chain protection.

Registry security is critical for maintaining the integrity and trustworthiness of MCP tool ecosystems. This guide covers secure registry operations, vetting processes, and supply chain security measures.

Secure Registry Architecture

Registry Security Components

# Secure registry implementation
import hashlib
import json
import time
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from dataclasses import dataclass
from cryptography.hazmat.primitives import hashes, serialization
from cryptography.hazmat.primitives.asymmetric import rsa

@dataclass
class RegistryEntry:
    tool_name: str
    version: str
    author: str
    metadata: Dict[str, Any]
    signature: str
    upload_time: float
    verification_status: str
    reputation_score: float

class SecureToolRegistry:
    def __init__(self):
        self.registry_db = {}
        self.signature_verifier = SignatureVerifier()
        self.reputation_system = ReputationSystem()
        self.malware_scanner = MalwareScanner()
        self.access_controller = RegistryAccessController()
        self.audit_logger = AuditLogger()
        
    def register_tool(self, tool_metadata: Dict, publisher_credentials: Dict) -> RegistrationResult:
        """Register new tool with comprehensive security checks"""
        
        # Validate publisher credentials
        publisher_validation = self.access_controller.validate_publisher(publisher_credentials)
        if not publisher_validation.valid:
            return RegistrationResult(
                success=False,
                reason="Invalid publisher credentials",
                error_code="INVALID_PUBLISHER"
            )
        
        # Verify tool signature
        signature_validation = self.signature_verifier.verify_signature(tool_metadata)
        if not signature_validation.valid:
            return RegistrationResult(
                success=False,
                reason="Invalid tool signature",
                error_code="INVALID_SIGNATURE"
            )
        
        # Scan for malware
        malware_scan = self.malware_scanner.scan_tool(tool_metadata)
        if malware_scan.malware_detected:
            return RegistrationResult(
                success=False,
                reason=f"Malware detected: {malware_scan.threat_type}",
                error_code="MALWARE_DETECTED"
            )
        
        # Check for name conflicts
        tool_name = tool_metadata['name']
        if self.is_name_conflict(tool_name, tool_metadata['author']):
            return RegistrationResult(
                success=False,
                reason="Tool name conflicts with existing tool",
                error_code="NAME_CONFLICT"
            )
        
        # Calculate initial reputation
        reputation_score = self.reputation_system.calculate_initial_reputation(
            tool_metadata,
            publisher_credentials
        )
        
        # Create registry entry
        entry = RegistryEntry(
            tool_name=tool_name,
            version=tool_metadata['version'],
            author=tool_metadata['author'],
            metadata=tool_metadata,
            signature=tool_metadata['signature'],
            upload_time=time.time(),
            verification_status="verified",
            reputation_score=reputation_score
        )
        
        # Store in registry
        self.registry_db[tool_name] = entry
        
        # Log registration
        self.audit_logger.log_tool_registration(entry, publisher_credentials)
        
        return RegistrationResult(
            success=True,
            reason="Tool registered successfully",
            entry=entry
        )
    
    def vetting_process(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> VettingResult:
        """Comprehensive tool vetting process"""
        
        vetting_checks = [
            self.check_metadata_integrity,
            self.check_code_quality,
            self.check_security_vulnerabilities,
            self.check_license_compliance,
            self.check_documentation_quality,
            self.check_test_coverage
        ]
        
        vetting_results = []
        
        for check in vetting_checks:
            result = check(tool_metadata)
            vetting_results.append(result)
            
            if result.severity == "critical" and not result.passed:
                return VettingResult(
                    passed=False,
                    reason=f"Critical vetting failure: {result.message}",
                    details=vetting_results
                )
        
        # Calculate overall vetting score
        vetting_score = self.calculate_vetting_score(vetting_results)
        
        return VettingResult(
            passed=vetting_score >= 70,  # 70% threshold
            score=vetting_score,
            details=vetting_results
        )
    
    def check_security_vulnerabilities(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> VettingCheckResult:
        """Check for security vulnerabilities in tool"""
        
        # Static analysis
        static_analysis = self.perform_static_analysis(tool_metadata)
        
        # Dependency analysis
        dependency_analysis = self.analyze_dependencies(tool_metadata)
        
        # Known vulnerability check
        vuln_check = self.check_known_vulnerabilities(tool_metadata)
        
        vulnerabilities = []
        vulnerabilities.extend(static_analysis.vulnerabilities)
        vulnerabilities.extend(dependency_analysis.vulnerabilities)
        vulnerabilities.extend(vuln_check.vulnerabilities)
        
        # Determine severity
        critical_vulns = [v for v in vulnerabilities if v.severity == "critical"]
        high_vulns = [v for v in vulnerabilities if v.severity == "high"]
        
        if critical_vulns:
            return VettingCheckResult(
                check_name="security_vulnerabilities",
                passed=False,
                severity="critical",
                message=f"Found {len(critical_vulns)} critical vulnerabilities",
                details=vulnerabilities
            )
        elif high_vulns:
            return VettingCheckResult(
                check_name="security_vulnerabilities",
                passed=False,
                severity="high",
                message=f"Found {len(high_vulns)} high severity vulnerabilities",
                details=vulnerabilities
            )
        else:
            return VettingCheckResult(
                check_name="security_vulnerabilities",
                passed=True,
                severity="info",
                message="No critical or high severity vulnerabilities found",
                details=vulnerabilities
            )

Supply Chain Security

Supply Chain Verification

# Supply chain security implementation
class SupplyChainSecurityManager:
    def __init__(self):
        self.provenance_tracker = ProvenanceTracker()
        self.dependency_analyzer = DependencyAnalyzer()
        self.sbom_generator = SBOMGenerator()
        self.integrity_verifier = IntegrityVerifier()
        
    def verify_supply_chain(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> SupplyChainResult:
        """Verify complete supply chain integrity"""
        
        # Track provenance
        provenance_result = self.provenance_tracker.track_provenance(tool_metadata)
        
        # Analyze dependencies
        dependency_result = self.dependency_analyzer.analyze_dependencies(tool_metadata)
        
        # Generate SBOM
        sbom = self.sbom_generator.generate_sbom(tool_metadata)
        
        # Verify integrity
        integrity_result = self.integrity_verifier.verify_integrity(tool_metadata, sbom)
        
        # Combine results
        supply_chain_secure = (
            provenance_result.verified and
            dependency_result.secure and
            integrity_result.valid
        )
        
        return SupplyChainResult(
            secure=supply_chain_secure,
            provenance=provenance_result,
            dependencies=dependency_result,
            sbom=sbom,
            integrity=integrity_result
        )
    
    def track_build_process(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> BuildProvenanceResult:
        """Track and verify build process"""
        
        build_info = tool_metadata.get('build_info', {})
        
        # Verify build environment
        build_env_result = self.verify_build_environment(build_info)
        
        # Verify build reproducibility
        reproducibility_result = self.verify_reproducibility(build_info)
        
        # Verify build attestation
        attestation_result = self.verify_build_attestation(build_info)
        
        return BuildProvenanceResult(
            verified=all([
                build_env_result.verified,
                reproducibility_result.verified,
                attestation_result.verified
            ]),
            build_environment=build_env_result,
            reproducibility=reproducibility_result,
            attestation=attestation_result
        )

Reputation System

Tool Reputation Management

# Reputation system implementation
class ReputationSystem:
    def __init__(self):
        self.reputation_db = {}
        self.feedback_processor = FeedbackProcessor()
        self.trust_network = TrustNetwork()
        self.reputation_calculator = ReputationCalculator()
        
    def calculate_reputation_score(self, tool_name: str) -> float:
        """Calculate comprehensive reputation score"""
        
        reputation_factors = {
            'author_reputation': self.get_author_reputation(tool_name),
            'usage_statistics': self.get_usage_statistics(tool_name),
            'user_feedback': self.get_user_feedback(tool_name),
            'security_history': self.get_security_history(tool_name),
            'code_quality': self.get_code_quality_score(tool_name),
            'maintenance_activity': self.get_maintenance_activity(tool_name)
        }
        
        # Weighted calculation
        weights = {
            'author_reputation': 0.2,
            'usage_statistics': 0.15,
            'user_feedback': 0.25,
            'security_history': 0.25,
            'code_quality': 0.1,
            'maintenance_activity': 0.05
        }
        
        reputation_score = sum(
            reputation_factors[factor] * weights[factor]
            for factor in reputation_factors
        )
        
        return min(max(reputation_score, 0.0), 1.0)
    
    def update_reputation(self, tool_name: str, event_type: str, event_data: Dict):
        """Update reputation based on events"""
        
        if event_type == "security_incident":
            self.handle_security_incident(tool_name, event_data)
        elif event_type == "user_feedback":
            self.handle_user_feedback(tool_name, event_data)
        elif event_type == "usage_statistics":
            self.handle_usage_statistics(tool_name, event_data)
        elif event_type == "code_update":
            self.handle_code_update(tool_name, event_data)
        
        # Recalculate reputation
        new_reputation = self.calculate_reputation_score(tool_name)
        
        # Update reputation database
        self.reputation_db[tool_name] = {
            'reputation_score': new_reputation,
            'last_updated': time.time(),
            'update_reason': event_type
        }
        
        # Propagate through trust network
        self.trust_network.propagate_reputation_update(tool_name, new_reputation)

Malware Detection

Malware Scanning System

# Malware detection system
class MalwareScanner:
    def __init__(self):
        self.static_analyzer = StaticAnalyzer()
        self.dynamic_analyzer = DynamicAnalyzer()
        self.signature_database = SignatureDatabase()
        self.heuristic_analyzer = HeuristicAnalyzer()
        
    def scan_tool(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> MalwareScanResult:
        """Comprehensive malware scan"""
        
        scan_results = []
        
        # Static analysis
        static_result = self.static_analyzer.analyze(tool_metadata)
        scan_results.append(static_result)
        
        # Dynamic analysis (sandboxed)
        dynamic_result = self.dynamic_analyzer.analyze(tool_metadata)
        scan_results.append(dynamic_result)
        
        # Signature-based detection
        signature_result = self.signature_database.scan(tool_metadata)
        scan_results.append(signature_result)
        
        # Heuristic analysis
        heuristic_result = self.heuristic_analyzer.analyze(tool_metadata)
        scan_results.append(heuristic_result)
        
        # Combine results
        malware_detected = any(result.malware_detected for result in scan_results)
        threat_level = max(result.threat_level for result in scan_results)
        
        return MalwareScanResult(
            malware_detected=malware_detected,
            threat_level=threat_level,
            scan_results=scan_results,
            scan_timestamp=time.time()
        )
    
    def analyze_suspicious_behavior(self, tool_metadata: Dict) -> SuspiciousBehaviorResult:
        """Analyze tool for suspicious behavior patterns"""
        
        suspicious_patterns = [
            self.check_network_activity,
            self.check_file_operations,
            self.check_process_manipulation,
            self.check_registry_access,
            self.check_obfuscation,
            self.check_anti_analysis
        ]
        
        detected_patterns = []
        
        for pattern_check in suspicious_patterns:
            result = pattern_check(tool_metadata)
            if result.detected:
                detected_patterns.append(result)
        
        # Calculate suspicion score
        suspicion_score = sum(pattern.score for pattern in detected_patterns)
        
        return SuspiciousBehaviorResult(
            suspicious=suspicion_score > 70,  # 70% threshold
            suspicion_score=suspicion_score,
            detected_patterns=detected_patterns
        )

Access Control

Registry Access Management

# Registry access control
class RegistryAccessController:
    def __init__(self):
        self.publisher_db = {}
        self.permissions_manager = PermissionsManager()
        self.authentication_service = AuthenticationService()
        self.authorization_service = AuthorizationService()
        
    def validate_publisher(self, credentials: Dict) -> PublisherValidationResult:
        """Validate publisher credentials and permissions"""
        
        # Authenticate publisher
        auth_result = self.authentication_service.authenticate(credentials)
        if not auth_result.authenticated:
            return PublisherValidationResult(
                valid=False,
                reason="Authentication failed",
                publisher_id=None
            )
        
        publisher_id = auth_result.publisher_id
        
        # Check publisher status
        publisher_info = self.publisher_db.get(publisher_id)
        if not publisher_info:
            return PublisherValidationResult(
                valid=False,
                reason="Publisher not found",
                publisher_id=publisher_id
            )
        
        if publisher_info['status'] != 'active':
            return PublisherValidationResult(
                valid=False,
                reason=f"Publisher status: {publisher_info['status']}",
                publisher_id=publisher_id
            )
        
        # Check permissions
        required_permissions = ['tool_upload', 'tool_update']
        if not self.permissions_manager.has_permissions(publisher_id, required_permissions):
            return PublisherValidationResult(
                valid=False,
                reason="Insufficient permissions",
                publisher_id=publisher_id
            )
        
        return PublisherValidationResult(
            valid=True,
            reason="Publisher validated successfully",
            publisher_id=publisher_id
        )
    
    def authorize_tool_access(self, user_id: str, tool_name: str, action: str) -> AuthorizationResult:
        """Authorize tool access based on user permissions"""
        
        # Get tool information
        tool_info = self.get_tool_info(tool_name)
        if not tool_info:
            return AuthorizationResult(
                authorized=False,
                reason="Tool not found"
            )
        
        # Check tool status
        if tool_info['status'] != 'active':
            return AuthorizationResult(
                authorized=False,
                reason=f"Tool status: {tool_info['status']}"
            )
        
        # Check user permissions
        user_permissions = self.permissions_manager.get_user_permissions(user_id)
        
        # Check action-specific permissions
        if action == 'download':
            if 'tool_download' not in user_permissions:
                return AuthorizationResult(
                    authorized=False,
                    reason="Download permission required"
                )
        elif action == 'update':
            if 'tool_update' not in user_permissions:
                return AuthorizationResult(
                    authorized=False,
                    reason="Update permission required"
                )
            
            # Check if user is tool owner
            if tool_info['author'] != user_id:
                return AuthorizationResult(
                    authorized=False,
                    reason="Only tool owner can update"
                )
        
        return AuthorizationResult(
            authorized=True,
            reason="Access authorized"
        )

Registry Monitoring

Registry Security Monitoring

# Registry monitoring system
class RegistrySecurityMonitor:
    def __init__(self):
        self.event_collector = EventCollector()
        self.anomaly_detector = AnomalyDetector()
        self.threat_intelligence = ThreatIntelligence()
        self.alert_manager = AlertManager()
        
    def monitor_registry_activity(self):
        """Monitor registry for security events"""
        
        # Monitor tool uploads
        self.monitor_tool_uploads()
        
        # Monitor download patterns
        self.monitor_download_patterns()
        
        # Monitor reputation changes
        self.monitor_reputation_changes()
        
        # Monitor access patterns
        self.monitor_access_patterns()
    
    def monitor_tool_uploads(self):
        """Monitor tool upload activities"""
        
        upload_events = self.event_collector.get_upload_events()
        
        for event in upload_events:
            # Check for suspicious uploads
            if self.is_suspicious_upload(event):
                self.alert_manager.create_alert(
                    alert_type="suspicious_upload",
                    severity="high",
                    message=f"Suspicious tool upload detected: {event.tool_name}",
                    details=event
                )
            
            # Check against threat intelligence
            threat_match = self.threat_intelligence.check_indicators(event)
            if threat_match.match_found:
                self.alert_manager.create_alert(
                    alert_type="threat_intelligence_match",
                    severity="critical",
                    message=f"Threat intelligence match: {threat_match.indicator}",
                    details=event
                )
    
    def is_suspicious_upload(self, event: UploadEvent) -> bool:
        """Check if upload event is suspicious"""
        
        suspicious_indicators = [
            # Rapid successive uploads
            self.check_rapid_uploads(event),
            
            # Unusual upload times
            self.check_unusual_timing(event),
            
            # Suspicious file characteristics
            self.check_file_characteristics(event),
            
            # Publisher reputation
            self.check_publisher_reputation(event),
            
            # Geographical anomalies
            self.check_geographical_anomalies(event)
        ]
        
        return any(suspicious_indicators)

Best Practices

Registry Security Guidelines

1. Multi-Factor Authentication: Require MFA for all publishers
2. Code Signing: Mandate code signing for all tools
3. Automated Scanning: Implement continuous malware scanning
4. Reputation Tracking: Maintain comprehensive reputation systems
5. Access Logging: Log all registry access and modifications
6. Incident Response: Establish clear incident response procedures
7. Regular Audits: Conduct regular security audits
8. Threat Intelligence: Integrate external threat intelligence feeds

Common Vulnerabilities

• Weak Authentication: Insufficient publisher authentication
• Malware Infiltration: Malicious tools in registry
• Reputation Gaming: Artificial reputation manipulation
• Access Control Bypass: Insufficient access controls
• Supply Chain Attacks: Compromised dependencies
• Metadata Manipulation: Falsified tool metadata

---

Registry Security provides essential protection for MCP tool ecosystems by ensuring the integrity, authenticity, and trustworthiness of distributed tools.